NICs follow the employment trail and not that of the paperwork

Employers pay secondary Class 1 National Insurance contributions (NICs) on their employees’ earnings, but an employer with no residence, presence or place of business in Great Britain is effectively outside the charge. Because employers’ NICs add to employment costs, some businesses try to avoid them by employing their workforce through an overseas company. One such attempt has just failed.

An anti-avoidance provision, the “host employer” rule, applies where a worker employed by a foreign employer has their personal service “made available” to a business in Great Britain and rendered for that business’s purposes. The host is then treated as the secondary contributor and must pay the employer’s NICs, whatever the contracts say. The rule considered here was the version in force before 6 April 2014, although it was later replaced by broader provisions.

The Company in question provides catering and hospitality services to North Sea offshore installations. It transferred its offshore crew to a US affiliate with no GB presence, while continuing to run the operation itself through its own offshore manual and onshore management. The First-tier Tribunal found the affiliate was little more than a contractual shell and that the Company exercised day-to-day control.

The Upper Tribunal dismissed the Company's appeal and upheld an assessment of over £6.8m, plus interest, for the period in question. Following its recent decision in Bilfinger Salamis, it held that the phrases “made available” and “rendered” require no element of control by the host. As such, it declined to depart from Bilfinger, as it was not satisfied that the decision was clearly wrong and that the Company retained the necessary control in either case.

The ruling does not, however, catch every subcontracting arrangement, and the Tribunal expressly said the outcome is sensitive to the facts. But changing who signs the employment contract will not avoid the charge where the workers’ services are in reality supplied to and used by a UK business, although this position is far from final. A renewed application for permission to appeal Bilfinger to the Court of Session was pending when judgement was given, and other Upper Tribunal appeals are outstanding, and so we may expect further deliberation. Until new light is shed upon the issue, employers would be wise not to muddy the waters by using offshore shell companies or other ghost employers.

Source:Employment Tribunal | 17-11-2026